To be honest I'm still not a fan of Peckinpah's particular BBQ style, but pounds for price they are still good, and when my no-carb friend wanted meat-meat-meat and we were both still stinging from Wildebeest, Peckinpah just naturally seemed to suggest itself.
OK, not really -- the front runners for me were Hog Shack (but Burnt Ends seemed to have fallen off the menu and they didn't respond to my e-mail about it), Memphis Blues (same problem as Hog Shack -- sweet BBQ sauces all over the meat), then Peckinpah in third place.
The menu is different since the last time I was there. No more sausage in The Divorce, for example. And no looks-like-swamp-weed Southern Greens as a choice of sides anymore.
The Divorce ($59.95, serves 3-6) One half serving of Pulled Pork, Pork Side Ribs (3), Beef Brisket, Chopped Beef, and Chicken Wings (3?), plus four sides and two pieces of cornbread.
- The amount of meat looks sort of disappointing and geared toward sharing with 3 people. No way this serves 6 a satisfactory amount of meat.
- If you choose the "correct" sides (read: heavy on carbs), you can get a medium-to-light meat but filling meal.
- Still not really sold on this style of BBQ, especially as some of the items (like the chicken and brisket) were dry and on the tough side. Ribs and pulled stuff were fine though.
- Definitely use their vinegar sauce to try to soften any tougher cuts.
- Honestly my favourite part of this was the "muffin" of cornbread.
- Slight jalapeño (?) bite to it jazzes this up and saves it from the same monotony / heaviness as hush puppies.
- Despite being called a "stew" it looked like assorted meat in soup.
- If you are not careful and just scoop out the meat, you will end up with a savoury soup, which you could possibly use as a dip for hushpuppies or cornbread.
- Decent quantity and quality but nothing special here.
- Three ping-pong ball sized balls.
- Sweet sauce provided looks viscous but is surprisingly runny. Watch out.
- It's a "real salad" with greens topped with a slab of tomato and a sprinkle of cranberries.
- Everything else could end up giving you a tired, heavy feeling, so you might want to consider choosing this for at least one of your sides no matter what.
- Felt overpriced for the quantity (less than a $9 order of Mean Poutine).
- Special cheese or not, it tasted only weakly of cheese flavour.
- Daily special (?). Not on the regular menu.
- Waste of time. Deep frying the oreos left you with what looked like a soggy half (?) oreo. Also, the thick batter meant you are competing with that to actually taste your oreo. Basically, the process doesn't really enhance the oreo at all.
- If you are desperate for a deep fried dessert, try Deep Fried Mars Bars instead.
- Generous amount of chewy batter. Thankfully you have the rather decent ice cream to accompany it.
After The Divorce, Mac 'n Cheese, Deep Fried Oreos, and drinks for each of us, the bill after tax but before tip was still under $25 per person, and we were stuffed.
Bonus Points: Whatever you want to say about Peckinpah, they feed you well for your money in an increasingly gentrified area of upscalish eats at upscalish prices.